Muscle injuries seen with MRI, ultrasound and thermography in soccer
MRI for a muscle injury in a soccer player is right? Is ultrasound better? What does thermography add? In today’s case study, we will see how all these imaging tests provide key information in the diagnostic process.
Muscle injury is considered one of the most frequent in the field of sport. This fact is especially relevant in sports that involve high-speed changes of direction, such as soccer, basketball, baseball, and American football. Epidemiological studies show that muscle injury in soccer accounts for more than 30% of all injuries. This implies a recurrence of between 1.8 and 2.7 muscle injuries per 1,000h of exposure, either training or competition (Green et al., 2020; Junge et al., 2006; Walden et al., 2005). Studies that show data separately, estimate that this musculature has an injury incidence of 0.5 per 1000h of training and between 3–4.1 per 1000h of competition (Ekstrand et al., 2016; Lempainen et al., 2015).
For a professional soccer team this represents about 12 muscle injuries per season. As a result, muscle injuries are equivalent to more than 300 days of absence from sports for the team in a season (Junge et al., 2006; Walden et al., 2005).
Case study: hamstring muscle injury in soccer
In this case study, we are going to take an in-depth look at the hamstring muscle injury of a soccer player, from three points of view:
- magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
- ultrasound image
- thermography image
Each imaging test has its strengths and weaknesses. And what is more interesting: the combination of different technologies allows us to better understand the pathology, its extension, severity and implications. Let’s discuss the pros and cons of these imaging tests.
Muscle injury through different imaging tests
Muscle injury is a type of musculoskeletal pathology that has been widely studied by different imaging tests. In addition to being very recurrent in acyclic sports, the quality of the diagnostic information depends on the intervention performed. Therefore, the decision made in cases of muscle injury should be based on diagnostic tests as accurately as possible.
Medical diagnosis is based mainly on the clinic and on two imaging tests: magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and ultrasound. Both structurally describe this lesion, so that its location, severity, extent and the presence or absence of bleeding can be known (Ahmad et al., 2013; Pollock et al., 2016).
MRI is the modality chosen when greater precision is desired and it is considered the reference test, but at a much higher cost than ultrasound. The optimal time to perform MRI is between the first 24 and 72 hours, since this is when there are already appreciable signs that allow quantifying the severity of the injury (Kerkhoffs et al., 2012).
ultrasound , on the other hand, has the advantage of being much cheaper, but technically-dependent and, as with MRI, the most important ultrasound findings are the visualization of the hematoma, the discontinuity of the muscle fibers and the length, width and depth of the lesion (Ahmad et al., 2013; Svensson et al., 2018), but evidently with a lesser degree of precision.
It is estimated that when this injury is diagnosed, around 13% of cases are not identified with MRI (Ekstrand et al., 2016), which opens the doors to other forms of diagnosis that have better sensitivity and / or specificity results. In this way, infrared thermography, among other technologies, is postulated as a candidate to aid in the diagnosis of musculoskeletal pathologies, especially in muscle injuries.
The muscle injury in thermography
The current scientific literature does not shed much light on this and there are only a few articles that speak on the subject. Even, sometimes, this information is very heterogeneous and contradictory, so we will detail the publications that exist to date.
- The only systematic review with meta-analysis on thermographic diagnosis of musculoskeletal disorders (Sanchis-Sánchez et al., 2014) does not include a single article on muscle injury , like other reviews of the literature (Santos et al., 2014).
- In this same sense, in another review of the literature (Bandeira et al., 2014) it is argued that after the muscle injury there is a temperature rise , based on scientific literature. However, in said literature, either they do not talk about muscle injury (Nola et al., 2012) or they say that it is hyperthermic (Ríos et al., 2011), but they are based again on other articles (Niehof, 2007; Pichot, 2001; Ríos et al., 2011), none of which speaks at any time of muscle injury, so the quality of this conclusion is doubtful to say the least.
- In another of their works (Bandeira et al., 2012), they propose a method to detect muscle injury in soccer by correlating hyperthermic thermographic images with creatinkinase biomarkers. They establish a correlation between an increase in temperature and micro-injuries, something evident in a non-injury post-exercise recovery process, but not in a macroscopic muscle injury. Therefore, by not taking into account either the clinic or other imaging tests, it seems clear that muscle injury in soccer is not related to an increase in temperature. Similar studies have been replicated (de Andrade et al., 2017) and it appears that temperature increases with muscle damage. You can see it in detail here.
- In an observational study with correlation with medical diagnosis (Sillero-Quintana et al., 2015), muscle injuries are described as hyperthermic, with a Increase in temperature of 0.3º C with respect to its healthy contralateral, on a sample of n = 15.
- By contrast, works carried out in animals (Turner, 1991), more specifically in Racehorses show evidence of the hypothermic pattern associated with muscle injury , where the injured area is significantly colder than its contralateral.
- Lastly, recently, the first publications that speak of the hypothermic profile in muscle injury in humans, specifically in soccer (dos Santos Bunn et al., 2020; Fernández & del Estal, 2020), one of them awarded for its originality in this discovery for the scientific community.
The muscle injury in our case study
This soccer player is 34 years old and participates in the second division B of Spain. During his career as an athlete, he has only had a myotendinous injury in the right rectus femoris. He claims to have had other complaints, such as low back pain and a slight right ankle sprain, but nothing remarkable.
At the moment of his injury, the athlete was training with his team in a +48h-post-match training, of which he played 90 minutes. The specific action in which the injury occurred was in a heel strike, as detailed in the example in image 1.
He was immediately withdrawn from training and given the day off, as the clinic indicated a hamstring muscle injury, very common in the world of football.
The following morning, he was sent for an MRI , which confirmed a grade II fibrillar tear in the proximal region of the long head of the biceps femoris, with an extension of 3cm and significant bleeding. Details can be seen in image 2A.
48h after the injury, a transverse and longitudinal ultrasound was performed, which can be seen in image 2B. This test indicated an irregular hypoechoic area, where the muscle retraction space has been occupied by the hematoma, confirming the same length and diagnosis.
Finally, at 36h, a thermography was performed, which we will detail later.
The muscle injury in soccer, seen with thermography: our case study
After showing the results of the lesion of our case study from the vision of the magnetic resonance image and the ultrasound, it is the turn of the themography. In image 3A we can see the thermogram of the posterior region of the legs. It is especially interesting to highlight the fact of an apparent loss of continuity in the representation of the temperature of the athlete’s left posterior thigh. Furthermore, if we compare with the representation of the same region on the right side, we qualitatively detect an interesting hypothermic asymmetry. In image 3C we can see the player’s own hand pointing to the exact area by asking where it hurts. The conclusion seems obvious, when relating the clinic to hypothermia in the same area, but we will still need the quantitative analysis. To do this, in image 3B we can observe the data of mean asymmetries, which return results below -0.3º C . The regions where the athlete reports pain appear in purple and the regions where an injury has been diagnosed are striped.
Summarizing the imaging tests in soccer muscle injury
To make its use more visible to aid in the diagnosis, we have adapted Table 1, based on the conclusions of the FC Barcelona Muscle Injury Clinical Practice Guide (Barcelona & Mèdics, 2009).
|DOMS||0||Inconsistent signs||Interstitial edema and increased local vascularization||Inconsistent signs|
|Fibrillar micro-rupture and / or muscle elongation||I||Minimal discontinuity solution||Increase in interstitial signal||Local signs of hypothermia|
|Fibrillar rupture||II||Clear muscle defect||Significant interstitial signal, focal muscle defect||Evident cold island, which affects the region|
|Muscle tear||III||Complete muscle and / or tendon disruption||Complete muscle and / or tendon disruption||Evident cold island, which affects the entire body segment|
In conclusion, we would like to highlight the need for quality scientific evidence, confirming or denying the appearance of significant hypothermias in the region diagnosed with muscle injury. From our clinical practice, based on more than 10 years of experience confronting muscle injuries, it seems convenient to emphasize that the muscle injury has this typical behavior of temperature drop.
Ahmad, C. S., Redler, L. H., Ciccotti, M. G., Maffulli, N., Longo, U. G., & Bradley, J. (2013). Evaluation and management of hamstring injuries. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 41(12), 2933-2947. https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546513487063
Bandeira, F., Moura, M. A. M., Abreu de Souza, M., Nohama, P., & Neves, E. (2012). Pode a termografia auxiliar no diagnóstico de lesões musculares em atletas de futebol? Rev Bras Med Esporte., 18, 234-239.
Bandeira, F., Neves, E. B., Moura, M. A. M. de, & Nohama, P. (2014). A termografia no apoio ao diagnóstico de lesão muscular no esporte. Revista Brasileira de Medicina do Esporte, 20, 59-64. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1517-86922014000100012
Barcelona, F. C., & Mèdics, S. (2009). Guía de Práctica Clínica de las lesiones musculares. Epidemiología, diagnóstico, tratamiento y prevención. Versión 4.5 (9 de febrero de 2009). Apunts: Medicina de l’esport, 179-203.
de Andrade Fernandes, A., Pimenta, E. M., Moreira, D. G., Sillero-Quintana, M., Marins, J. C. B., Morandi, R. F., … & Garcia, E. S. (2017). Skin temperature changes of under-20 soccer players after two consecutive matches. Sport Sciences for Health, 13(3), 635-643.
dos Santos Bunn, P., Miranda, M. E. K., Rodrigues, A. I., de Souza Sodré, R., Neves, E. B., & Bezerra da Silva, E. (2020). Infrared thermography and musculoskeletal injuries: A systematic review with meta-analysis. Infrared Physics & Technology, 109, 103435. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.infrared.2020.103435
Ekstrand, J., Waldén, M., & Hägglund, M. (2016). Hamstring injuries have increased by 4% annually in men’s professional football, since 2001: A 13-year longitudinal analysis of the UEFA Elite Club injury study. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(12), 731-737. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2015-095359
Fernández, I., & del Estal, A. (2020, noviembre 20). Thermal profile description of most common soccer injuries by Infrared Thermography: Case studies.
Green, B., Bourne, M. N., van Dyk, N., & Pizzari, T. (2020). Recalibrating the risk of hamstring strain injury (HSI): A 2020 systematic review and meta-analysis of risk factors for index and recurrent hamstring strain injury in sport. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 54(18), 1081-1088. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2019-100983
Junge, A., Langevoort, G., Pipe, A., Peytavin, A., Wong, F., Mountjoy, M., Beltrami, G., Terrell, R., Holzgraefe, M., Charles, R., & Dvorak, J. (2006). Injuries in team sport tournaments during the 2004 Olympic Games. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 34(4), 565-576. https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546505281807
Kerkhoffs, G., Van Es, N., Wieldraaijer, T., Sierevelt, I., Ekstrand, J., & Dijk, van, Niek. (2012). Diagnosis and prognosis of acute hamstring injuries in athletes. Knee surgery, sports traumatology, arthroscopy : official journal of the ESSKA, 21. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-012-2055-x
Lempainen, L., Banke, I. J., Johansson, K., Brucker, P. U., Sarimo, J., Orava, S., & Imhoff, A. B. (2015). Clinical principles in the management of hamstring injuries. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy: Official Journal of the ESSKA, 23(8), 2449-2456. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-014-2912-x
Niehof, S. (2007). Video thermography: Complex regional pain syndrome in the picture. Undefined. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Video-thermography%3A-complex-regional-pain-syndrome-Niehof/92af16d760cddcf8f5bb6f21a8ec850a95acdf12
Nola, I. A., Gotovac, K., & Kolarić, D. (2012). Thermography in Biomedicine—Specific Requirements. Proceedings of ELMAR-2012, 54th International Symposium ELMAR-2012. https://www.bib.irb.hr/917563
Pichot, C. (2001). Aplicación de la termografía en el dolor lumbar crónico. Rev. Soc. Esp. Dolor, 43-47.
Pollock, N., Patel, A., Chakraverty, J., Suokas, A., James, S. L. J., & Chakraverty, R. (2016). Time to return to full training is delayed and recurrence rate is higher in intratendinous (‘c’) acute hamstring injury in elite track and field athletes: Clinical application of the British Athletics Muscle Injury Classification. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(5), 305-310. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2015-094657
Quintana, M., Fernández-Jaén, T., Fernández Cuevas, I., Carmona, P., Arnaiz-Lastras, J., Pérez, M.-D., & Guillén, P. (2015). Infrared Thermography as a Support Tool for Screening and Early Diagnosis in Emergencies. Journal of Medical Imaging and Health Informatics, 5, 1223-1228. https://doi.org/10.1166/jmihi.2015.1511
Ríos, M. M., Chacón, E. M., Fernández, Á. C., & Guillén, E. O. (2011). Termografía infrarroja y el estudio de riesgos de lesiones músculo esqueléticas. Revista Ingeniería Industrial, 10(1), 55-67.
Sanchis-Sánchez, E., Vergara-Hernández, C., Cibrián, R. M., Salvador, R., Sanchis, E., & Codoñer-Franch, P. (2014). Infrared thermal imaging in the diagnosis of musculoskeletal injuries: A systematic review and meta-analysis. AJR. American Journal of Roentgenology, 203(4), 875-882. https://doi.org/10.2214/AJR.13.11716
Santos, M. G. R. dos, Silva, L. G. C. da, Júnior, J. R. de S., Lemos, T. V., & Matheus, J. P. C. (2014). Thermographic: A tool of aid in physical therapy diagnosis – literature review. Manual Therapy, Posturology & Rehabilitation Journal, 1-8.
Svensson, K., Eckerman, M., Alricsson, M., Magounakis, T., & Werner, S. (2018). Muscle injuries of the dominant or non-dominant leg in male football players at elite level. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy: Official Journal of the ESSKA, 26(3), 933-937. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-016-4200-4
Turner, T. A. (1991). Thermography as an aid to the clinical lameness evaluation. The Veterinary Clinics of North America. Equine Practice, 7(2), 311-338. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0749-0739(17)30502-3
Walden, M., Hagglund, M., & Ekstrand, J. (2005). UEFA Champions League study: A prospective study of injuries in professional football during the 2001–2002 season. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 39(8), 542-546. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsm.2004.014571
If you have any comments or clarifications, feel free to send us a message. We will be delighted to read you.